"Brilliant, singular, and astounding."
— David Fear, Rolling Stone
"An audacious, potently unflinching, and profoundly humanistic gut-punch of a film."
— Carlos Aguilar, The Playlist
"The standout of this year’s Sundance Film Festival competition, in terms of both audacity of subject and maturity of execution."
— Peter Debruge
"Josephine is a special, hard-to-stomach yet immaculately handled movie that demands your attention ... fearlessness is Beth de Araújo’s superpower."
— Matt Donato, TheWrap
"As the adults navigate the moral and legal fallout, Reeves anchors the film with a heartbreaking, remarkably mature performance that announces her as a major new talent."
— Peter Howell, Toronto Star
"Josephine simply would not work without a performance from a child actor as capable as Reeves. Her powerful turn is easily one of the best performances from a child actor this century."
— George Bate, Screen Rant
"Josephine is a heartbreaking film, but not without hope. It’s brilliant in its performances and gives us Channing Tatum's best. This also proves that Beth de Araújo is one of our bravest new voices."
— Kristy Strouse, Film Inquiry
"There are some images in 'Josephine' that are hard to watch, but it also contains some ambitious, graceful, humanist filmmaking, a true merging of storytelling and the visual medium of film. After all, sometimes words aren’t enough."
— Brian Tallerico, RogerEbert.com