"Glorious production, with gorgeous music, dancing."
— Nell Minow, Common Sense Media
"Arguably one of the best translations to film of any Broadway musical."
— Barbara Saltzm, Los Angeles Times
"A quintessential slice of Americana, featuring wonderful music, engaging characters, and an uplifting story."
— John J. Puccio, Movie Metropolis
"DaCosta's musical is one of the most exuberant and purely enjoyable of the lot. Much of this is down to the infectious energy of Robert Preston, reprising his stage role as smooth-talking conman."
— Paul Howlett, The Guardian
"Zestily performed and choreographed, beautifully shot by Robert Burks, full of standards like '76 Trombones' and 'Till There Was You', and endowed with a warming nostalgia for old-fashioned ways."
— Geoff Andrew, Time Out
"It's here, and the rich, ripe roundness of it, the lush amalgam of the many elements of successful American show business that Mr. Willson brought together on the stage, has been preserved and appropriately made rounder and richer through the magnitude of film."
— Bosley Crowther, The New York Times